2020 Porsche 911 Carrera S 992 vs. Carrera 4S 992 against one another on track

We’ve been here before, right? A new 911, which among our fraternity will forever be known as the 992. In Porsche’s model line there’s nothing more significant, even if today 911 sales are a mere support act to the SUV bottom line. Simply put, the 911 remains the company’s icon, the car that defines the firm. The 911 represents success on road and track, a million-selling sports car that’s instantly recognisable; unique in the automotive world.

Which is why replacing it is about as difficult a task as Porsche has. Time doesn’t stand still though, and the 911 has to evolve to work in the world it finds itself in. That evolution has unquestionably allowed it to endure and succeed, but the transitional points in its lifecycle will always be significant and debated ad-infinitum among drivers and the likes of me in titles like this.

The 911 matters to people then, more so than any other car. It doesn’t actually seem like that long ago I was reviewing the then new 991, or indeed 991.2; in the time since they’ve gone on to become the 911, after the usual difficult transition period where everyone is looking dewy-eyed about the outgoing model. I’ll do that now, the Carrera T manual that I’d borrowed off the UK press fleet in anticipation of driving the new 992 feeling pretty much perfect to me. That 991 should be good though, it being at the end of its development cycle.

Everything learned from that and more has been adopted here with the 992. There are two of them here today, a Carrera S and Carrera 4S. They are, as all will be until the standard Carrera arrives later this year, PDK, and pulling the right paddle shifter here can now be done eight times. “They’re the same,” is the reply when I request that both cars feature in the same shot.

Visually, that’s true; the Carrera S and Carrera 4S are identical, even more so when they’re painted the same Racing yellow. The only clue to the 4S’s additional drive is the badge on its backside. Choose the model delete option, or better still the simple 911 numbering, and you’d not know it’s a four, Porsche’s decision to make all Carreras widebody removing that go-to identifier of drive. It’s big, this new 911, as wide as the outgoing GTS and GT3, a bit longer and taller, as well as heavier. We’ll get to that later.

The dynamics engineers certainly weren’t complaining when the decision to go widebody was made. You might think that it was the chassis engineers that dictated it, but the 992’s a widebody for different reasons, key among them being the cooling. The 992’s 3.0-litre twin turbo flat-six has to pass ever-tighter laws for economy and emissions, and an efficient turbo engine is a cool one. That defines not just the physicality of the 911’s shape, but the large cooling intakes fed by active vanes at the 992’s nose. Here, now, in natural light and in the pitlane of the Hockenheimring, I have to say it looks good. It’s unmistakably 911, as it should be, design boss Mauer’s team having dipped into the 911’s past to bring it forward. From the cut-out recess on the bonnet to the SC-aping font for the rear 911 badging, via the large headlights sitting upright (cut exclusively out of the wings rather than puncturing the bumper), there’s no mistaking its lineage.

That expansive rear is spanned by an LED strip light across its entire width, the slightly recessed lighting and three-dimensional Porsche badge across the back leaving you in no doubt that you’re following a 911. The pop-up rear wing that aids stability now also acts as an airbrake when stopping from speed. It’s better integrated than that on the 991, but is still arguably an inelegant if undeniably effective solution to the 911’s aerodynamic Achilles heel. It’s the other pop-out element to the new 911 that’s causing the most debate here today; the door handles. They look neat, but their operation isn’t perfect, feeling insubstantial and not always popping out to greet you. That you have to lift and pull rather than simply grab counts against them too. A small thing, perhaps, but they feel like the answer to a question nobody asked, particularly in comparison to those on a 991.

Once inside, this is clearly a 911 for a new era. The quality takes a leap, the build feeling substantial, the materials, too. It’s an attractive cabin, the centre dash coming with a near 11-inch screen containing all the info and entertainment functions. It’s a touchscreen, adding connectivity and configurability to your nav and entertainment that you probably never knew you wanted or, arguably, needed. Choose the Sport Chrono and you’ll be able to select the driving modes via the Mode switch on the steering wheel, that alone worth the option price. Underneath the PCM sit five toggle switches. The first two are programmable here (or being Wet or Sport modes if you’ve not optioned Sport Chrono) the remaining three being the hazards, PSM and, in this car, PDCC.

There’s a dominant analogue rev counter ahead of you, as it should be, its redline at 7,400rpm. Either side of it are screens, configurable again, aping the layout of the 991, with either conventional-style dials or various choices of nav, entertainment or drive mode display. They’re bright and clear, if slightly obscured from view by the optional GT Sport version of the steering wheel. That option adds not just some sizeable contouring over the standard steering, but some fussy detailing. The standard steering wheel loses none of the functionality of the GT Sport one, looks neater, and affords a better view of those instruments.

Attached to the wheel are the paddle-shifters, which is the only means of manually shifting the PDK. The small gear selector on the neat centre console only offers Park, Neutral and Drive, denying those drivers who like to use the PDK stick to go up and down the ‘box the opportunity to do so. It’s not an issue for me, but I know of a number of drivers who still like to do so, Andreas Preuninger being among them. Keyless operation means there’s no need to take the key from your pocket, Porsche retaining the ignition on the opposite side to the shifter, it requiring a twist like a key, retaining some semblance of mechanical connection that’s infinitely preferable to a push-button.

Doing so fires the same capacity 3.0-litre flat-six of its predecessor. It’s dubbed the 9A2 evo, having being significantly revised to improve economy. There’s a 200 bar Piezo injector system, new turbochargers, optimised fuelling, a new cast manifold, reduced internal friction, a higher compression ratio and reduced consumers scavenging power. The result of that is 450hp and 530Nm, the peak torque arriving a little bit later in the rev range than the 991’s. That’s a by-product of the fitment of a petrol exhaust fitment, something that US-specification cars do without for now, it having no other negative effect on the performance or indeed sound, according to Porsche. Having heard both back-to-back on the pre-drive in San Francisco, the particulate filter does impact on the engine’s sound, muting it a bit, making the Sports Exhaust a must-tick option if you want to hear the 911’s flat six sounding its best. In isolation it’s fine, but the knowledge that it could sound better still rankles a touch. Emissions necessity trumps aural pleasure, then, but there’s little else to complain about, the bulk of the work on the engine also having benefits to how it reacts.

If there’s any lag it’s infinitesimal, the 9A2 evo unit building on the already strong performance of the 9A1 unit of the 991. The ample low-rev torque delivers huge flexibility, yet with peak power arriving at 6,500rpm there’s incentive to rev it out, the reward being a linear shove that’s more super than sports car, the 911’s performance now such it’s moved on a league. In the Carrera S that means a 0-62mph time of 3.7 seconds, 0-100mph in 8.1 seconds and a 191mph top speed, that 0-62mph time dropping to 3.5 seconds if you opt for Sport Chrono and 0-100mph time to 7.8 seconds. Do the same in the 4S and the additional traction gains it 0.1 seconds for a 0-62mph time of 3.6 seconds or 3.4 seconds with Sport Plus in Launch Control. In both you’ll need sixth gear if you’re planning on reaching the maximum speed, seventh and eighth being geared for cruising economy.

Seventh and eighth are redundant today then, with the Hockenheimring to drive it’s all about assessing the nuances between the Carrera S and its 4S alternative. The temptation to hammer around the track fully lit is sizeable, but a couple of sighting laps in both reveal that, badges aside, you genuinely would be hard pushed to tell there’s any drive being apportioned to the front axle in the 4S. Both cars are equipped with PCCB brakes for when the speed does inevitably rise around here, which given not just the speeds possible, but the increased weight of the 992, is no bad thing.


ABOVE Twin oval exhaust pipes signify Sports exhaust, a must-have option if you wish to enjoy the aural delights of the turbo’d flat six. ABOVE AND LEFT 992 has clear styling cues from previous 911 generations, though the pop-out door handles are an unconvincing creep towards automation. ABOVE Even on track, you’d be hard pressed to tell the difference between the rear-drive and all-wheel drive 992. ABOVE Kyle gets to grips with the 992, including its five new ‘shortcut’ toggle keys situated below the PCM. ABOVE It’s bigger and laden with more tech than ever, but crucially the 992 still drives like a proper Porsche 911.

992 Carrera S (and 4S)

Model Year 2019/2020


Capacity 2,981cc

Compression ratio 10.5:1

Maximum power 450hp @ 6,500rpm

Maximum torque 530Nm @2,300-5,000rpm

Transmission Eight-speed PDK


Front Spring-strut suspension; wheels independently suspended on wishbones with trailing links and struts (McPherson type, Porscheoptimized); dynamic anti-roll bar

Rear Lightweight multi-link suspension with wheels independently guided on five suspension arms; dynamic anti-roll bar

Wheels & tyres

Front 8.5×20-inch; 245/35ZR20

Rear 11.5×21-inch; 305/30ZR21


Length 4,548mm

Width 1,852mm

Weight 1,515kg (1,565kg 4S)


0-62mph 3.5secs (3.4 secs 4S)

Top speed 191 (190mph 4S)

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 4.4 / 5. Vote count: 12

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.